RefGuard: Reference Integrity for Scientific Manuscripts
RefGuard checks every reference in your manuscript against the published record, flagging retracted papers, hallucinated citations, and references that do not support your claims. It also shows you the quality, diversity, and balance of your bibliography, so you know how your citations hold up before anyone else looks.
Why Reference Integrity Matters
References carry the weight of a manuscript’s claims, and they fail quietly. A cited paper can be retracted years after publication. AI writing tools can invent citations that look perfectly real. A source can be cited for something it never actually says. Reviewers and editors check references, and increasingly, so do automated screening systems at journals.
Finding these problems before submission protects the work, the authors, and everyone who builds on it afterwards.
Retractions Keep Getting Cited
Retracted papers continue to accrue citations years after withdrawal, carrying discredited findings into new work.
AI Writing Tools Invent References
Language models can generate citations that look plausible but do not exist in the published record.
Claims Outrun Their Citations
A reference can be real and still fail to support the claim it is attached to.
Reviewers and Editors Check First
Reference quality shapes the first impression a manuscript makes at submission and in review.
Retracted Papers. Hallucinated References. Unsupported Claims.
The reference problems most likely to end in rejection, revision, or correction. RefGuard surfaces all of them before peer review or editorial scrutiny.
Retracted References
Citations that point to papers retracted after publication, cross-referenced with a proprietary retraction database.
Hallucinated References
References that do not exist in the published record, including citations invented by AI writing tools.
Unsupported Claims
Citations that do not support the claim they are attached to, shown with the mismatch in context.
RefGuard also warns about risks that are often overlooked during preparation, such as sources detected as paratexts rather than published papers, and references that may be outdated.
Inside the RefGuard Report
One upload produces a complete, navigable report of your bibliography.
Dashboard
Your manuscript’s overall reference quality at a glance: risk levels, scores, and quick links to each analysis page.
Risk Analysis
Flags potential issues in your citations. Major issues indicate confirmed retractions; warnings cover paratexts and less recent sources.
Quality Analysis
Four scores, Quality, Impact, Recency, and Diversity, that show how balanced and well-rounded your reference list is.
Comparative Insights
See how your citation patterns compare with field averages.
Reference Explorer
A detailed, sortable list of every reference, each shown in context, with filters and export.
From Upload to Insight
Upload Upload your manuscript.
RefGuard Analyzes Every reference is checked against the published record.
Review A dashboard of risk levels, each finding in context, and the full reference explorer.
Trusted by Leading Institutions and Publishers












250K+ Manuscripts
Scanned using Proofig AI to uphold research integrity
Global
Trust
Adopted by top-tier publishers, journals, and research institutions
Seamless Integration
Integrated into pre-submission and editorial screening workflows
Integrity Support
Used by researchers, editors, and ethics officers worldwide
Built for Everyone Who Depends on Citations
Researchers
Check your bibliography before submission, while every fix is still easy.
Research Institutions
Screen references in every manuscript before it leaves the institution.
Publishers
Screen submissions for retracted, hallucinated, and unsupported citations at the desk.
Part of Proofig AI
RefGuard is a Proofig AI product. It also powers the reference integrity check inside PubShield and Octym.
Proofig AI
Image integrity. Detect manipulation, duplication, plagiarism, self-plagiarism, and AI-generated figures.
PubShield
The all-in-one integration hub. Best-in-class checks from leading providers, returned to one dashboard.
Octym
The unified platform. Every integrity and quality check in one review, configured to how you work.
See RefGuard on Your Own Manuscript
RefGuard: frequently asked questions
What is RefGuard?
RefGuard is Proofig AI’s reference integrity product: it checks a manuscript’s reference list before submission or at the editorial desk. RefGuard flags citations to retracted papers, hallucinated or invented references, and citations that do not support the claims they are attached to, and it points out incomplete or broken references. It also powers the reference integrity check inside PubShield, for publishers and research institutions, and inside Octym, which reviews the entire paper.
Can RefGuard detect hallucinated references?
Yes, RefGuard, Proofig AI’s reference integrity product, detects hallucinated references, the citations that look real but point to no real publication. RefGuard compares each reference with the scholarly publishing record to confirm the article is real, and flags the ones it cannot match so you can check them before an editor or reviewer does. That is where citations invented by AI writing tools surface, along with references too garbled to trace.
Can RefGuard find citations to retracted papers in my reference list?
Yes, RefGuard, Proofig AI’s reference integrity product, flags citations to retracted papers in a manuscript’s reference list, using a proprietary retraction database. Each flagged citation shows the reason, the date and the type of notice, so you can read what the notice says before you decide. Authors can then replace the retracted source, or keep it only where their text discusses the retraction, and say so.
Can RefGuard tell me when a citation does not support my claim?
Yes, RefGuard, Proofig AI’s reference integrity product, checks that each citation supports the claim it is attached to. RefGuard flags statements that need a source but have none, and cited sources that do not fit the claim or that contradict it. Each flag is shown with the claim in context, so an author or editor can decide whether to add, replace or keep the citation.
Who is RefGuard for?
RefGuard is for researchers, research institutions and publishers who need the references in a manuscript to hold up. Researchers check their references before they submit, while every fix is still easy. Institutions screen manuscripts before they leave the institution. Publishers and editorial offices screen submissions for retracted, hallucinated and unsupported citations before peer review, and integrity teams can check the references of published papers too. RefGuard is Proofig AI’s reference integrity product.
What does the RefGuard report show?
The RefGuard report shows every flagged reference with the reason it was flagged, so you know what to fix and why. It also shows publication years, citation counts, open-access share and the most-cited journals, so you can see whether your sources are current and well balanced. The RefGuard app adds Quality, Impact, Recency and Diversity scores, notes references 15 or more years old, and exports the sortable, filterable reference list to CSV.
Can I trust RefGuard's results?
RefGuard’s results show you where to look, and each flag comes with the reason it was raised. You can open the source behind any flag, confirm or dismiss it, and decide what to change. A flag is a signal for a person to review, not a verdict on a reference or its authors. RefGuard supports your own checks rather than replacing them, and verifying references stays your responsibility, as Proofig AI’s Terms of Service state.
Can RefGuard spot incomplete or incorrect references in my manuscript?
Yes, RefGuard shows the published details beside each citation as written, so a wrong year or a missing author is easy to spot. You can then fix the entry before you submit. References that cannot be matched to a real publication are flagged too, because that is where hallucinated citations surface. RefGuard is Proofig AI’s reference integrity product.
Further Resources
Journals can screen references at submission with a desk check of each manuscript's reference list before peer review. The desk check covers four problems: citations...
Proofig AI checks far more than images. Its image checks detect duplication, manipulation, plagiarism, self-plagiarism and AI-generated figures. RefGuard, Proofig AI's reference integrity product, flags...
To check that a citation supports its claim, read the claim, open the cited paper and ask whether the source says the same thing, something...
To detect hallucinated references before you submit, check each entry against the published record: open its DOI and confirm it leads to the same paper,...
To check whether a paper you cite has been retracted, open each reference at its DOI or journal page, look for a retraction notice, and...
AI-generated scientific images are entering the published literature, and visual inspection alone cannot reliably catch them. Proofig AI's AI-Generated Image Identification capability is built specifically...